16
…
“Al-Tabarani recorded it in all three of his Muʿjams with a good chain.”
Al-Haythami says the same, adding: “Al-Tabarani related it in the three collections, and its transmitters are reliable.”
A further supporting narration comes from Abu Saʿid al-Khudri. Ibn Abi Shaybah (1/89/2 = 1/257, no. 2960), al-Tayalisi (no. 294), and Ahmad (3/56) transmit it through ʿAli b. Zayd → Saʿid b. al-Musayyib → him, as a marfuʿ report with similar wording. Al-Suyuti remarks in Tanwir al-Hawalik, “Its isnad is sound.” That, however, is open to objection, for ʿAli b. Zayd (Ibn Judʿan) is disputed; al-Taqrib rates him “weak,” so his solitary report is not dependable. Nevertheless, his narration is acceptable as corroborative evidence, as is the case here.
Another support comes from al-Nuʿman b. Murrah. Malik included it in the Muwattaʾ (1/181) via Yahya b. Saʿid from him; this is a mursal chain but its isnad is authentic.
The wording of al-Nuʿman b. Murrah’s report is: “What do you think about the drinker, the thief, and the fornicator?”—this was before the legal penalties concerning them were revealed. They replied, “Allah and His Messenger know best.” He said, “They are grave offenses that incur punishment, and the worst kind of theft is when a person steals from his prayer.”
Al-Baji says:
..............................................................................
" رواه الطبراني في " معاجمه الثلاثة " بإسناد جيد ".
وكذا قال الهيثمي؛ إلا أنه قال:
" رواه الطبراني في " الثلاثة "، ورجاله ثقات ".
ومنها: عن أبي سعيد الخُدْري.
أخرجه ﴿ابن أبي شيبة (١/٨٩/٢) = [١/٢٥٧/٢٩٦٠] ﴾ ، والطيالسي (٢٩٤) ،
وأحمد (٣/٥٦) من طريق علي بن زيد عن سعيد بن المسيب عنه مرفوعاً نحوه. وقال
السيوطي في " تنوير الحوالك ":
" إسناده صحيح ".
كذا قال! وعلي بن زيد - وهو: ابن جُدْعان -: مختلف فيه. وفي " التقريب ":
" ضعيف ". فلا يصح حديثه.
نعم؛ حديثه حسن لا بأس به في الشواهد - كما هنا -.
ومنها: عن النعمان بن مُرّة.
أخرجه مالك في " الموطأ " (١/١٨١) عن يحيى بن سعيد عنه.
وهذا مرسل صحيح الإسناد.
ولفظ حديث النعمان بن مُرَّة:
" ما ترون في الشارب والسارق والزاني؟ "، وذلك قبل أن تنزل فيهم الحدود.
قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم. قال:
" هن فواحش، وفيهن عقوبة. وأسوأ السرقة الذي يسرق من صلاته ".
قال الباجي: