Silsilat al-Ahadith al-SahihahNasir al-Din al-Albani

Hasan ibn Salih said:

“A stone struck the Prophet’s foot, causing it to bleed, and he said: …” He then cited the hadith.

It was narrated by al-Tabarani (1707), and its chain is authentic.

Shuʿbah also narrated it in abbreviated form, as recorded by Ahmad (4/312), al-Ruyani (2/164), and al-Tabarani (1704).

ʿAli ibn Salih—the brother of Hasan ibn Salih—also narrated it, as recorded by al-Tabarani (1706).

ʿUmar ibn Ziyad al-Hilali said (1):

“A tree struck the Prophet’s finger”—thus it is stated—“causing it to bleed, and he said: …” He then cited it, adding:

“He was carried and placed upon a bed woven of palm fronds or straps. A leather cushion stuffed with fibre was placed beneath his head, and the straps left marks on his side. Then ʿUmar ibn al-Khattab came and wept. He said, ‘What is making you weep?’ He replied, ‘O Messenger of Allah! Chosroes and Caesar sit upon beds of gold and wear silk brocade and heavy silk!’ He said, ‘Are you not content that they should have this world, while you have the Hereafter?!’”

It was narrated by al-Tabarani (1719) and Ibn Saʿd (1/466).

I say: This addition is invalid. Its hidden defect—besides its contradiction of the preceding narrations—is this al-Hilali, concerning whom al-Bukhari said in al-Tarikh (6/156/2012): “Some of his reports are recognized, while others are rejected.”

(1) The original reads: “Amr ibn Ziyad al-Alhani.” The correction is based on al-Bukhari’s Tarikh and other biographical dictionaries, as well as al-Majma‘, 10:327.
وقال حسن بن صالح: أصاب رِجلَ النبي ﷺ حجَرٌ، فدميت، فقال ... الحديث. أخرجه الطبراني (١٧٠٧) ، وسنده صحيح. وتابعهم- با ختصار-: شعبة؛ عند أحمد (٤/ ٣١٢) ، والرُّويا ني (١٦٤/ ٢) ، والطبراني (١٧٠٤) . وعلي بن صالح- أخو حسن بن صالح- عند الطبراني أيضاً (١٧٠٦) . وقال عمر بن زياد الهلالي (١) : أصابت إصبع النبي ﷺ شجرة (كذا) فدميت فقال: ... فذكره، وزاد: فحُمل فوضع على سرير مرمول بخوص أو شريط، ووضع تحت رأسه مرفقة من أدم حشوها ليف، فأثر الشريط في جنبه، فجاء عمر بن الخطاب فبكى، فقال: "ما يبكيك؟ "، فقال: يا رسول الله! كسرى وقيصر يجلسون على سرير من الذهب، ويلبسون الديباج والإستبرق! قال: "أما ترضى أن لهم الدنيا ولكم الآخرة؟! ". رواه الطبراني (١٧١٩) ، وا بن سعد (١/٤٦٦) . قلت: فهذه الزيادة باطلة، وعلتها- مع المخالفة للروايات السابقة- الهلالي هذا " فقد قال البخاري فيه في "التاريخ " (٦/١٥٦/٢٠١٢) : "تعرف وتنكر".
(١) الأصل (عمرو بن زياد الألهاني) ! والتصحيح من "تاريخ البخاري "، وغيره من كتب الرجال، و"المجمع " (١٠/٣٢٧) .

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies