by which you may be guided, and through which Allah guided Muhammad. Abū Bakr is the companion of the Messenger of Allah—may Allah bless him and grant him peace—the second of the two. He is the Muslim most entitled to take charge of their affairs, so rise and pledge allegiance to him.” A group of them had already pledged allegiance to him in the portico of Banī Sā‘ida; the general pledge of allegiance took place at the pulpit (1).
Another chain of transmission (2) in al-Bukhārī gives the following wording:
“To proceed: Allah chose for His Messenger what is with Him over what is with you. This is what He used to guide His Messenger, so hold fast to it and you will be guided. It was only (3) through this that Allah guided His Messenger—may Allah bless him and grant him peace.”
Al-Bukhārī included this in the Book of Holding Fast to the Sunnah (4).
Al-Bukhārī also reported that ‘Āisha said concerning this incident:
“Allah brought benefit through every sermon the two of them delivered. ‘Umar certainly frightened the people (5), among whom there was hypocrisy, and Allah thereby brought them back. Then Abū Bakr made the people see the guidance and made the truth known to them (6)”—the truth that was binding upon them.
The accounts of his composure and serenity in the shelter on the day of Badr and on the day of al-Hudaybiyya are also well known. In this he surpassed (7) all the other Companions, so how can he be accused of