Question: Does this not also extend to wrongful deeds—acts that, if a person is tried by them, he should at the very least keep concealed?
Answer: You mean publicizing crimes and exposing sinners? Yes, that too is included. Yet His statement, “except the one who has been wronged,” sets up a contrast between two parties—the wronged and the wrong-doer—and it permits the wronged person to speak out with harsh words against the one who oppressed him.
***
Exegesis of Sura al-Māʾidah
Question: I would like you to explain Allah’s words: “Forbidden to you are carrion, blood, the flesh of swine, that which has been dedicated to other than Allah, the strangled, the beaten, the fallen, the gored, what a predator has partially eaten—unless you are able to slaughter it—and that which has been sacrificed on stone altars” (5:3). Are the fallen animal (al-mutaraddiyah) and the gored animal (al-naṭīḥah) unlawful to eat only when they die immediately from the fall or the goring, or is it still unlawful if they linger for some time and you then slaughter them?
Answer: Allah addresses His believing servants—whom He called at the outset of this great sura with the words, “O you who believe, fulfil your covenants” (5:1)—saying: “Forbidden to you is carrion” (5:3), that is, Allah has forbidden you to eat an animal that dies without the lawful ritual slaughter. An explicit text makes an exception for the carrion of fish and locusts, as the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, said: “Two kinds of carrion and two kinds of blood have been made lawful for us. As for the two kinds of carrion, they are fish and locusts.” Thus the dead fish and locust are lawful, and everything else remains forbidden.