the night and day, and that He is the Creator and Provider for His servants, allotting them differing lifespans and provisions, making some rich and others poor. He knows what is best for each of them, and who deserves wealth and who deserves poverty. He thus states that He alone creates all things and governs them. If that is so, why worship anyone besides Him? Why place one’s trust in anyone besides Him? Just as He alone holds dominion, He alone should be worshipped. Allah Most High often establishes His sole right to worship on the basis of their acknowledgment of His oneness in lordship. The polytheists acknowledged this, as they used to say in their pilgrimage invocation: ‘Here I am at Your service. You have no partner except a partner who belongs to You; You own him and whatever he owns.’”1
Shaykh al-Islām Ibn Taymiyyah said: “As for lordship, they acknowledged it. Allah Most High says:
‘And if you asked them who created the heavens and the earth, they would surely say, “Allah.”’ 2
And He says:
‘Say, “To whom belongs the earth and whoever is in it, if you know?” They will say, “To Allah.”’
up to His words:
‘Then how are you deluded?’ 3
None of them ever believed that the idols were the ones who sent down rain, provided for the world, and governed it. Rather, their polytheism consisted in what we have mentioned: they took rivals besides Allah whom they loved as they loved Allah.”4
Al-Maqrīzī said: “There is no doubt that the polytheists did not deny Allah’s oneness in lordship. Rather, they acknowledged that He alone—glory be to Him—is their Creator and the Creator of the heavens and the earth, and that He attends to the needs of the whole of creation. What they denied was His oneness in worship and love.”5