Mukhtasar al-Uluww lil-Ali al-AzimA-Dhahabi

The second specious objection concerns “direction.”

Its reply is what Ibn Taymiyyah states in his al-Tadmuriyyah, p. 45: The word “direction” (jihah) may be intended as something that exists apart from Allah, in which case it is a created thing—such as when by “direction” one means the very Throne or the heavens themselves. It may also be intended as something that is not an entity independent of Allah—namely, what lies above the universe.

It is well-known that the revealed texts neither affirm nor deny the term “direction” itself; what they do affirm is Allah’s exaltedness (ʿulūw), His rising over the Throne (istiwāʾ), His being above (fawqiyyah), the ascension to Him, and the like. Moreover, it is established that nothing exists except the Creator and the created, and the Creator—exalted is He—is wholly distinct from His creation: none of His essence is inside His creatures, and none of what He has created is inside His essence.

الشبهة الثانية: الجهة والجواب عنها ما قاله ابن تيمية في "التدمرية" "ص٤٥": قد يراد بـ"الجهة" شيء موجود غير الله, فيكون مخلوقا كما إذا أريد بـ"الجهة" نفس العرش, أو نفس السماوات, وقد يراد به ما ليس بموجود غير الله تعالى, كما إذا أريد بالجهة ما فوق العالم. ومعلوم أنه ليس في النص إثبات لفظ الجهة ولا نفيه, كما فيه إثبات العلو والاستواء والفوقية والعروج إليه ونحو ذلك, وقد علم أن ما ثم موجود إلا الخالق والمخلوق, والخالق ﷾ مباين للمخلوق, ليس في مخلوقاته شيء من ذاته, ولا في ذاته شيء من مخلوقاته.

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies