16
Accordingly, to protest that “the ḥudūd should not be enforced against him” is a flawed question even on their own premises, for they do not acknowledge Allah’s will in many forms of disobedience. The legal penalties become binding upon him solely because the deed is wholly his—such as drinking wine—although he committed it by Allah’s will, exalted is He.
فَلم تجر عَلَيْهِ الْحُدُود سُؤال فَاسد على أصلهم لأَنهم لَا يثبتون مَشِيئَة الله تَعَالَى فِي كثير من الْمعاصِي فَلَا تلْزمهُ الْحُدُود الا على فعله جَمِيعًا مثل شرب الْخمر وَقد فعلهَا بِمَشِيئَة الله تَعَالَى