Al-Ḥārith said, “Shield me until I have finished digging, for by Allah I shall carry through what I have been commanded to do.” When they realized that he would not give up, they let him dig and left him alone. He had hardly worked at all before the stone lining of the well appeared; he exclaimed “Allāhu akbar!” and knew that the vision had been true. As he kept on digging he uncovered two golden gazelle figures that the tribe of Jurhum had once buried there, as well as some fine Qalaʿī swords and coats of mail.
Quraysh said to him, “ʿAbd al-Muṭṭalib, we have a share and a rightful claim in this.”
He replied, “No. Come, let us agree on a fair procedure between me and you: we shall cast lots with the arrows.”
They asked, “How shall we do that?”
He said, “I shall assign two arrows to the Kaʿbah, two to me, and two to you. Whatever pair of arrows is drawn for an item will take it; anyone whose arrows are not drawn shall have no share.”
They answered, “You have dealt justly.”
He therefore allotted two yellow arrows to the Kaʿbah, two black arrows to himself, and two white arrows to them. They gave the arrows to the man who cast lots before Hubal—Hubal being their greatest idol. (That is why Abū Sufyān cried on the Day of Uhud, “Exalt Hubal!”—meaning this very idol.) Meanwhile ʿAbd al-Muṭṭalib stood invoking Allah.
Yūnus ibn Bukayr relates from Muḥammad ibn Isḥāq that ʿAbd al-Muṭṭalib was saying:
O Allah, You are the praised King;
My Lord, You are the Originator, the One who will restore.
You hold firm the massive, anchoring rock;
With You lies both the new gift and the ancestral treasure.
If You so will, You inspire as You choose
Concerning the place of ornaments and iron.
So make plain today what You intend,
For I have vowed the long-standing vow.
Grant it, my Lord, and I shall never turn back.
The lot-caster threw the arrows: the two yellow arrows fell for the gazelles in favour of the Kaʿbah; the two black arrows fell for the swords and coats of mail in favour of ʿAbd al-Muṭṭalib; the two arrows of Quraysh were not drawn. ʿAbd al-Muṭṭalib then fashioned the swords into a door for the Kaʿbah and fixed the two golden gazelles to the door. According to their account, this was the first gold ever used to adorn the Kaʿbah. Thereafter he undertook the watering of the pilgrims from Zamzam.
Ibn Isḥāq and others also relate that Mecca had many wells before Zamzam re-emerged in the time of ʿAbd al-Muṭṭalib, and he went on to list them