the Children of Israel?’—that is: you left them and came to me even though I had charged you with their care. Moses then prayed:
“My Lord, forgive me and my brother, and admit us into Your mercy; You are the Most Merciful of the merciful.”
Yet Aaron—upon him be peace—had already forbidden them this atrocious deed in the strongest terms and rebuked them most sternly. Allah, exalted is He, says:
“Aaron had said to them beforehand, ‘My people, you have only been put to trial by this [calf]; your Lord is the All-Merciful, not this [idol]. So follow me and obey my command.’ They replied, ‘We will never cease to devote ourselves to it until Moses returns to us.’”
Thus Allah bears witness for Aaron—and Allah’s testimony suffices—that he forbade and scolded them, but they would neither obey him nor follow him.
Moses then turned to the Sāmirī: “What was it that moved you, O Sāmirī?” He said, “I perceived what they did not perceive. I saw Gabriel riding a horse, so I grasped a handful of dust from the trace of the Messenger’s steed and cast it in.”
Some relate that wherever the horse’s hoof struck the ground, greenery sprang forth; the Sāmirī took some of that soil, and when he threw it into the calf that had been fashioned from gold, what happened, happened. Hence his words: “So I flung it in, and thus my soul prompted me.”
Moses said, “Then begone! Throughout your life you will say, ‘Do not touch [me]’”—a curse upon him that no one touch him, as retribution for his having touched what he had no right to touch: a punishment in this world. He was then threatened with the next life: “And you have an appointment that you will not fail to keep” (another recitation: “that you will not break). “Now look at your god to which you remained devoted: we shall burn it, then scatter its ashes into the sea.”
Moses, peace be upon him, accordingly burned the calf—Qatādah and others say by fire; others, such as ʿAlī and Ibn ʿAbbās, relate that he filed it down, a view also found among the People of the Book—then scattered it in the sea. He ordered the Children of Israel to drink from that water; whoever had worshipped the calf had some of its ashes cling to his lips—others say their complexions turned yellow.
Allah then reports Moses as proclaiming to them, “Your only god is Allah; there is no deity but Him. His knowledge encompasses all things.” And He says: “Those who took the calf [as a god]—wrath from their Lord and disgrace in the life of this world shall overtake them; thus do We recompense the fabricators.”