Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

denied it. For those among the Mu'tazilah and Ash'arīs who deny direction say that He is neither in a direction nor outside it. Someone who says this is like someone who affirms the existence of one thing alongside another, yet holds that neither one's existence precedes or follows the other's.

He said: “Furthermore, ordinary people make no distinction between saying, ‘I sought it but did not find it anywhere,’ and saying, ‘I sought it, only to find that it did not exist.’” Thus, they explained that what is firmly rooted in human nature is that saying, “I sought it but did not find it anywhere”—indicating that they did not perceive it in any location—is equivalent to saying, “It turned out not to exist.” For the opposite of the nonexistent is something that is where a finder can find it.

ينفيها ولأن من نفى الجهة من المعتزلة والأشعرية يقولون ليس هو في جهة ولا خارجًا منها وقائل هذا بمثابة من قال إثبات موجود مع وجود غيره ولا يكون وجود أحدهما قبل وجود الآخر ولا بعده قال ولأن العوام لايفرقون بين قول القائل طلبته فلم أجده في موضع ما وبين قوله طلبته فإذا هو معدوم فبينوا أن المستقر في فطر الناس أن قولهم طلبته فلم أجده في موضع ما هو يدل على أنهم لم يحسوه في أين من الأيون هذا بمنزلة قولهم فإذا هو معدوم لأن ضد المعدوم هو ما يكون حيث يجده الواجد

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies