Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

And if they disagree with them—as is their position—they are told: “If you say that no one draws near to Allah Himself, that no one is called to Allah Himself, that no path—straight or circular—connects the servant to Allah Himself, and that no one goes to Allah Himself; and if, according to you, all this refers instead to some of the effects of His power and His creations, such as what He creates as a means of showing mercy to His servants, so that it is to these that one goes and towards these that one journeys—then, if you say this, you have no way to refute the position of those unionists. Your position is of the same kind as theirs, except that they have extended its scope, holding that whoever calls people to anything, reaches it, or journeys towards it has in fact called people to Allah, reached Him, and journeyed towards Him. You, however, restrict this to some created things rather than others. Thus, the difference between you and them is one of universal versus restricted application, and you resemble them more closely than the Christians do.”

This is why the author of al-Fusūs used to say that the Christians fell into unbelief only because they restricted its scope, since, in his view, all

وإن خالفوهم وهو قولهم قيل لهم إذا قلتم إن الله لا يتقرب إليه نفسه أحد ولا يدعى إليه نفسه أحد وليس بين العبد وبينه نفسه طريق مستقيم ولا مستدير وأنه لا يذهب إليه نفسه أحد وإنما ذلك كله عندكم يعود إلى بعض مقدوراته ومخلوقاته مثل ما يخلقه مما يرحم به العباد فإليها يذهب وإليها يسير فإذا قلتم هذا لم يكن لكم طريق إلى إفساد قول أولئك الاتحادية إذ قولكم من جنس قولهم إلا أنهم توسعوا في ذلك فجعلوا كل من دعا إلى شيء أو وصل إليه أو سلك إليه فإنما دعا إلى الله ووصل إليه وسلك إليه وأنتم تخصون ذلك ببعض المخلوقات دون بعض فالفرق بينكم وبينهم فرق ما بين العموم إلى الخصوص ومشابهتكم لهم أقرب من مشابهة النصارى لهم ولهذا كان يقول صاحب الفصوص إن النصارى إنما كفروا لأنهم خصصوا إذ عنده أن جميع

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies