Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

Sixth, he said: “The believer draws near to his Lord, Most High, on the Day of Resurrection, and He places His covering over him.” Yet he offered only this explanation: “Know that what is meant by His nearness and drawing close is the nearness of His mercy and its drawing close.” This does not explain the hadith, because he has treated the two instances of drawing near as one and the same. This is confusion, as already explained.

However, he did not give the full interpretation known from the Jahmiyyah. They said: “We understand it to mean that He brings him near to His mercy, reward, affection, and kindness. This is permissible in the language, and what is meant is standing and elevation in rank.” Although this interpretation of theirs is false, it is nevertheless something an advocate of figurative interpretation could say about this hadith, unlike the explanation he gave. We shall now demonstrate its falsity.

Seventh, we say: The mercy, īmān, and other things to which the servant is brought near must be either entities subsisting in themselves or attributes subsisting in something else. If they are attributes, it is well known that nearness to an attribute is possible only through nearness to the one possessing that attribute. Thus, the servant cannot be brought near to the mercy or īmān subsisting in Allah unless he is brought near to Allah Himself. As for his drawing near to an attribute subsisting in Him without drawing near to Him Himself, its falsity and unsoundness are evident. Hence, none of the worshippers has said this. Rather, whoever considers nearness to Him Himself impossible

السادس أنه قال يدنو المؤمن من ربه تعالى يوم القيامة فيضع عليه كنفه وهو لم يذكر إلا قوله اعلم أن المراد من قربه ودنوه قرب رحمته ودنوها وهذا ليس بتفسير لهذا الحديث لأنه جعل القربين شيئاً واحداً وهذا تخليط كما تقدم لكن هو لم يستوف التأويل المعروف عن الجهمية قالوا نحمل على أنه يقربه من رحمته وإثابته وتعطفه ولطفه وهذا سائغ في اللغة والمراد به المنزلة وعلو الدرجة فهذا التأويل الذي ذكروه وإن كان باطلاً لكنه هو الذي يمكن المتأول أن يقوله في هذا الحديث بخلاف ما ذكره ونحن نبين بطلانه فنقول الوجه السابع أن ما يدني إليه العبد من الرحمة والإيمان وغير ذلك إما أن تكون أعيانا قائمة بأنفسها أو صفات قائمة بغيرها فإن كانت صفات فمعلوم أن القرب إلى الصفة لا يكون إلا بالقرب إلى الموصوف نفسه فلا يمكن أن يقرب العبد إلى ما يقوم بالله من رحمة وإيمان إلا إذا قرب من نفسه فأما قربه من صفته القائمة به دون قربه من نفسه فظاهر البطلان والفساد ولهذا لم يقله أحد من العباد بل الذي يحيل القرب إلى نفسه

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies