Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

that the essence in question cannot exist, or cannot be conceived as existing, except in this manner, then this is something we accept.

The fifteenth argument: This consequence applies to all the descendants of Adam and to everyone who acknowledges the existence of anything whatsoever. For within what exists, one thing must be distinguishable from another. As for the Necessary Existent, distinction is even more evident in Him, since He is more perfect and complete. He must therefore be distinguished from other existing things by the distinctiveness of His necessarily existent essence, while sharing with them existence in its general sense.

This affirms two meanings, one of which can be known without the other being known. Either one is negated on the assumption that the other is absent, or it is not negated. If it is not negated, one must be identical with the other, which is impossible. Even if that were admissible, it would also be admissible in the analogous case. There would thus be no difference between making one of two realities distinguished in the mind identical with the other, and making one of several distinct spatial regions identical with another. And if it is not negated, composition from two or more attributes necessarily follows. The same applies to His being an intellective subject, an object of intellection, and intellect, exercising providence, being an agent and a necessitating cause of what is other than Himself, and to all the other

أن تلك الذات لا يمكن وجودها أو لايعقل وجودها إلا على هذا الوجه فهذا مما نلتزمه الوجه الخامس عشر أن هذا يلزم سائر بني آدم وسائر من أقرَّ بوجود شيء ما فإن الموجود لابد أن يتميز منه شيء عن شيء وأما الوجود الواجب فالتميز فيه أظهر لأنه أكمل وأتم فلابد أن يتميز عن غيره من الموجودات بخصوص ذاته الواجبة مع مشاركته لها في عموم الوجود وهذا إثبات لمعنيين يُعلم أحدهما مع عدم العلم بالآخر فإما أن ينفي أحدهما مع تقدير عدم الآخر أو لا ينفي فإن لم ينفِ لزم أن يكون أحدهما عين الآخر وهو محال وإن جاز ذلك جاز ذلك في نظيره فلا فرق بين أن تُجعل الحقيقتان المتميزتان في الذهن إحداهما عين الأخرى أو يجعل الحيزات المتميزات أحدهما عين الآخر وغن لم ينف لزم التركيب من صفتين وأكثر فكذلك القول في كونه عاقلاً ومعقولاً وعقلاً وذي عناية وفاعلاً وموجباً لغيره وسائر

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies