Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

Fourth, they affirm His existence, knowledge, power, and the like on the basis that He resembles others described in these terms.

Fifth, they assert likeness to creation in the attributes they acknowledge from revelation. Thus, they apply analogy and assert likeness in what they affirm through reason, what they acknowledge from revelation, and the attributes they deny, whether revealed or established by reason. They also liken Him to deficient and nonexistent things. These, then, are the five ways in which they set others equal to Allah and associate partners with Him.

Their denial of His attributes likewise takes several forms:

First, denying what the revealed names and attributes signify.

Second, denying truths established by reason.

Third, describing Him through privative attributes that do not entail existence. Such attributes can belong only to something nonexistent.

Fourth, combining two contradictories, which characterizes that which does not—and cannot—exist.

Their opponents, by contrast, base their argument on a fortiori reasoning, which is valid according to both revelation and reason. Through such reasoning, they establish that He must be above and separate from creation, and rule out the possibility that neither of two contradictory predicates applies to Him. For His being above the world, although known through the innate disposition, is also established by demonstrative rational arguments founded on a fortiori reasoning, as follows:

الرابع أن ما يثبتونه مثل وجوده وكونه عالماً قادراً ونحو ذلك يثبتونه على مماثلته لما يوصف بهذه الأمور الخامس أن ما أقروه من الصفات الشرعية أثبتوا فيه المماثلة فهم يثبتون المقايسة والمماثلة فيما يثبتونه بالعقل وفيما يقرونه من الشرع وفيما ينفونه من الصفات الشرعية ومن الصفات العقلية ويمثلونه أيضاً بالناقصات والمعدومات فهذا عدلهم وإشراكهم بالله من هذه الوجوه الخمسة وأما تعطيلهم فمن وجوه أيضاً أحدها نفي مضمون السماء والصفات الشرعية والثاني نفي الحقائق العقلية والثالث وصفه بالصفات العدمية التي لاتستلزم وجوداً وهذه الصفات لاتكون إلا لمعدوم الرابع جمعهم بين النقيضين وهذا هو صفة المعدوم الممتنع وأما منازعوهم فحجتُهم مبناها على قياس الأَولَى والأحرى وهذه حق في الشرع والعقل فإنهم أوجبوا عُلوَّه ومباينته ومنعوا خُلوَّّه عن النقيضين بقياس الأولى وذلك أن علوه على العالم مع أنه معلوم بالفطرة فهو ثابت أيضاً بالأقيسة العقلية البرهانية التي مبناها على الأولى والأحرى وذلك

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies