Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

an anonymous line of poetry, not composed by any known poet whose words could serve as authoritative evidence. If being established here meant taking possession, the statement would convey nothing of significance, for Allah’s dominion and power already encompass everything: every region and place in the heavens and the earth, and everything beneath the soil. What purpose, then, would singling out the Throne serve?

Moreover, taking possession properly applies when access to something has been prevented; once it is secured, one is said to have taken possession of it. What obstruction was there, then, for Him to be described as taking possession afterward? Likewise, if He were everywhere, as they claim, there would be no purpose in singling out the Throne. Thus, the meaning can only be what revelation indicates.

If it is said, “Attributing the Throne to Him is like attributing the House to Him. Just as He did not make the House to dwell in it, He likewise did not make the Throne to be upon it and establish Himself over it,” the reply is: “The Throne is not like the House in the respect you mention. Houses are built as rooms, ordinarily to provide protection against heat, cold, and similar forms of harm. Allah is exalted above such attributes. Thrones and royal seats, however, are adopted only as means of displaying majesty and greatness. Your analogy equating the two is therefore invalid.”

ببيت مجهول لم يقله شاعر معروف يصح الاحتجاج بقوله ولو كان معنى الاستواء هاهنا الاستيلاء لكان الكلام عديم الفائدة لأن الله قد أحاط ملكه وقدرته بكل شيء من الأشياء وبكل قطر وبقعة من السموات والأرض وما تحت الثرى فما معنى تخصيصه العرش بالذكر ثم إن الاستيلاء يتحقق معناه عند المنع عن الشيء فإذا وقع الظفر قيل استولى عليه فأي منع كان هناك حتى يوصف بالاستيلاء بعده وكذلك لو كان بكل مكان كما زعموا لم يكن بتخصيصه العرش بالذكر فائدة فثبت أنه ليس المعنى إلا ما أشار إليه التوقيف فإن قيل إن إضافة العرش إليه كإضافة البيت إليه وهو ل يجعله ليسكنه فكذلك لم يجع العرش للكينونة والاستواء عليه قيل إن العرش لا يشبه البيت فيما ذكرتموه وذلك لأن البيوت تتخذ غرفاً وعادة لتكون وقاية من الحر أو البرد وما أشبههما من وجوه الأذى والله متعالٍ عن هذه الصفات والعرش والسرير إنما يتخذ ليتمجد ويستكبر بهما فقياسكم لجمع بين الاثنين قياس فساد

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies