Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

is incompatible with being al-Samad (the Self-Sufficient), for al-Samad is He who has no hollow interior: He neither eats nor drinks nor begets, and nothing issues from Him, including any of the other wastes discharged by human beings. For a body to enter Him or leave Him would entail a deficiency involving something privative, which is incompatible with being al-Samad. This is not among the predicates established for existence as such, but among those involving existence or nonexistence. Consequently, its cause cannot be a characteristic common to both the Necessary Existent and contingent beings. Rather, it is a characteristic peculiar to contingent, originated beings: need and dependence. Food is needed to replace what the body loses through its breakdown, while ejaculation serves to avert the harm caused by semen, much as blood is drawn when necessary.

The presence within a body of another body that opposes and harms it constitutes an incapacity and need peculiar to created beings. Likewise, its need for a body outside itself, through which its existence is sustained, constitutes a dependence and need peculiar to created beings. Thus, the people of Paradise eat, drink and have intercourse, but they neither urinate, spit, blow their noses, defecate nor ejaculate. Rather, their food is eliminated through perspiration like musk

ينافي الصمدية فإن الصمد هو الذي لا جوف له فلا يأكل ولا يشرب ولا يلد ولا يخرج منه شيء ولا غيره من جنس الفضلات التي تخرج من الإنسان فإن دخول جسم فيه أو خروج جسم منه يتضمن النقص المستلزم لأمر عدمي وهذا ينافي الصمدية وليس هو من الأحكام الثابتة لمحض الوجود بل من الأحكام المتضمنة وجوداً أو عدماً فلا جرم لم يكن سبب ذلك وصفاً يتناول الواجب والممكن بل وصف يختص بالممكن المحدث وهوالحاجة والافتقار في الطعام لإخلاف بدل ما يتحلل من البدن وفي الإنزال لدفع الضرر الحاصل بسبب المني بمنزلة إخراج الدم عند الحاجة فوجود جسم فيه يضاده ويضاره عجز وفقر من خصائص المخلوق وحاجته إلى جسم خارج منه يتم به وجوده فقر وحاجة من خصائص المخلوق ولهذا كان أهل الجنة يأكلون ويشربون وينكحون ولا يبولون ولا يبصقون ولا يتمخطون ولا يتغوطون ولا يمنون وإنما يتحلل الطعام عنهم برشح كرشح المسك

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies