Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

and all its affairs come about through His will and command?

The seventeenth point: Your statement, “It follows that the Creator is deficient in Himself and derives His perfection from something other than Himself,” holds only if spatial location and direction are other than Him. That, in turn, would hold only if spatial location and direction were something separate from Him. But if spatial location is His limit and boundary, while direction is His being such that He can be pointed to, then there would be nothing here that is other than Him, according to those who affirm the attributes and maintain that His attributes are not other than Him.

For anyone who calls this “other,” saying that He derives His perfection from something other than Himself would be like saying that He derives His perfection from His knowledge, power, and life. This is equivalent to saying that He derives His perfection from Himself. This is not impossible; rather, it is necessary. Discussion of His perfection is like discussion of His existence.

We have already discussed the statement, “He is necessary in Himself,” and the attributes encompassed by it, explaining that He cannot exist without the attributes proper to His essence. Indeed, nothing whatsoever can exist otherwise. Thus, to posit their absence is to deny all existing things. We have also discussed the terms “other,” “spatial location,” “dependence,” and the like. The same applies to

وبمشيئته وأمره يكون جميع شئونه الوجه السابع عشر قولك يلزم أن يكون الباري ناقصاً بذاته مستكملا بغيره إنما يصح إذا كان الحيز والجهة غيراً له وذلك إنما يصح لو كان الحيز والجهة أمراً منفصلاً عنه فأما إذا كان الحيز هو حده ونهايته فالجهة كونه بحيث يشار إليه لم يكن هناك غيراً له عند الصفاتية الذين يقولون ليست صفاته غيره ومن سمى هذا غيراً كان قوله مستكملاً بغيره كقوله مستكملاً بعلمه وقدرته وحياته وذلك مثل قوله مستكملاً بنفسه وهذا ليس بممتنع بل هو واجب كالكلام في كماله كالكلام في وجوده وقد تقدم الكلام في قول القائل هو واجب بنفسه وما يدخل في ذلك من صفاته وأنه لا يكون موجوداً إلا بما تستحقه ذاته من صفاته بل لا يكون موجود قط إلا كذلك ففرض عدم ذلك جحد لجميع الموجودات وتكلمنا على لفظ الغير والحيز والافتقار ونحو ذلك وكذلك القول في

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies