Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

does not require a temporal interval separating the act from the agent. Thus you say, “I moved my hand, and so my garment moved,” or “my ring moved,” and the like. The hand’s movement precedes the movement of the ring and sleeve, yet both occur at the same time. Likewise, if this particular determination is contingent and comes about by His will and choice, that does not preclude His preceding His act with a priority that is not temporal.

Although the philosophers maintain this much concerning His priority over the world, these groups do not maintain it in that connection. Rather, they maintain it concerning His priority over this act subsisting in His own person and His being in a particular spatial region. They hold the same concerning all the particular utterances and acts attributed to Him that subsist in His own person, where He can say or do something else by His will and choice. This is a position known to be held by many groups among his opponents, including speculative theologians, adherents of hadith, Sufis, and others.

لا يوجب أن يكون بزمان يفصل بين الفعل والفاعل كما تقول حركت يدي فتحرك ثوبي أو تحرك خاتمي ونحو ذلك فحركة اليد متقدمة على حركة الخاتم والكم ومع هذا فزمانهما واحد فكذلك إذا كان هذا التخصيص جائزًا وهو بمشيئته واختياره لم يمنع ذلك أن يكون متقدمًا على فعله تقدمًا بغير الزمان وهذا القدر وإن كان الفلاسفة يقولونه في تقدمه على العالم فهؤلاء لم يقولوه في ذلك بل قالوه في تقدمه على هذا الفعل القائم بنفسه والتحيز المعين وهم يقولون ذلك في سائر ما يضاف إليه من أعيان الأقوال وأعيان الأفعال القائمة بنفسه التي يمكن أن يقول ويفعل غيرها مما يكون بمشيئته واختياره وهذا قول طوائف كثيرة من منازعيه معروف عنهم من أهل الكلام وأهل الحديث والصوفية وغيرهم

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies