Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

and the Hand. As for his statement that the Karrāmīs do not affirm this, it may be so if he means some of them. Otherwise, there is no doubt that some of them affirm these attributes known through revelation, such as the Face and the Hand, which he calls limbs and parts. They also use the term “body,” either merely as a word or in both word and meaning.

As for the Hanbalīs, none of them is known to use this term. Some, however, negate it, while others neither negate nor affirm it. The latter was the position of Imam Ahmad and the other imams of the Sunnah, although they nevertheless affirm what the revealed texts convey, which their opponents call corporealism and likening Allah to His creation. Indeed, they say that affirming these meanings more fully embodies the meaning of corporealism than the position of someone who affirms

واليد فقوله عن الكرامية إنهم لا يثبتون ذلك إن أراد به بعضهم فلعله يكون وإلا فلا ريب أن فيهم من يثبت هذه الصفات الخبرية كالوجه واليد التي يسميها هو الجوارح والأبعاض ويطلقون أيضًا لفظ الجسم إما لفظًا وإما لفظًا ومعني وأما الحنبلية فلا يعرف فيهم من يطلق هذا اللفظ لكن فيهم من ينفيه وفيهم من لا ينفيه ولا يثبته وهوالذي كان عليه الإمام أحمد وسائر أئمة السنة وإن كانوا مع ذلك يثبتون ما جاءت به النصوص مما يسميه المنازعون تجسيمًا وتشبيهًا بل يقولون إثبات هذه المعاني أحق بمعنى التجسيم ممن يثبت

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies