Bayān Talbīs al-JahmiyyaIbn Taimiya

must judge Him as one would a created being, since He would be within a created being, or a created being would be within Him. Since it is impossible for our Lord to enter into created beings and thus become part of them, or for them to enter into Him and thus become part of Him, we find no third possibility other than that He is separate from the things He created. They neither enter into Him nor touch Him, and He neither enters into them nor touches them. Were this not so, He would have the same status as they do.

“If they say, ‘Then He must have length and breadth,’ they are told, ‘This is impossible, for He is one, unlike other beings that are one, and great, with a greatness that cannot be measured against created beings. Just as He is great and knowing, unlike those who know, so too He is one and great, unlike others that are one and great.’ If you say, ‘A great being can only be divisible,’ you are told, ‘Then a knowing being can only be divisible, as must a hearing or seeing being—for you are reasoning by analogy with created beings.’”

Ibn Fūrak said: “Some have reported from Ibn Kullāb that

لزمه أن يحكم فيه بحكم المخلوق إذ كان في المخلوق أو المخلوق فيه فلما استحال في ربنا أن يداخل المخلوقين فيكون بعضاً لهم أو يداخلوه فيكونوا بعضاً له لم نجد منزلة ثالثة غير أنه بائن بخلق الأشياء فهي غير داخلة فيه ولا مماسة له ولا هو داخل فيها ولا مماس لها ولولا أن ذلك كذلك كان حكمه حكمها فإن قالوا فيعتقبه الطول والعرض قيل لهم هذا محال لأنه واحد لا كالآحاد عظيم لا تقاس عظمته بالمخلوقات كما أنه كبير عليم لا كالعلماء كذلك هو واحد عظيم لا كالآحاد العظماء فإن قلت العظيم لا يكون إلا متجزيًا قيل لك والعليم لا يكون إلا متجزيًا وكذلك السميع والبصير لأنك تقيس على المخلوقات قال ابن فورك وحكى حاكون عن ابن كلاب أنه

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies