to withdraw into solitude and cease keeping company with people. Mālik wrote back to him, saying: “Allah has apportioned deeds among His servants just as He has apportioned their provision. One man may be enabled to excel in prayer but not in fasting; another may be enabled to excel in fasting but not in prayer; and another may be enabled to excel in one thing but not another.” He listed several things, then said: “I do not think that what you are engaged in is better than what I am engaged in. Both of us are pursuing good, Allah willing. Peace be upon you.”
Section
Clarifying the Meaning of Faith and Islam
No act of worship is valid without first acknowledging and believing in the One worshipped. The foremost obligation is therefore to believe in Allah Most High, His oneness, the attributes of His essence and His acts, His angels, His Books, His messengers, and everything they brought from Him.
Faith is assent in the heart. Allah, Mighty and Majestic, says:
“You will not believe us”—that is, you will not accept what we say—“even if we are truthful.” [Joseph: 17]
Islam, by contrast, is the outward profession and declaration of faith. The word is derived from submission, meaning compliance, for whoever professes faith has complied and submitted to its rulings being applied to him. Thus every believer is a Muslim, since whoever holds faith inwardly professes it outwardly. Yet not every Muslim is a believer, for the hypocrite and the heretic outwardly profess Islam while inwardly holding unbelief. They are therefore Muslims outwardly but unbelievers inwardly. Islam is thus broader in scope than faith.
This applies in the land of Islam and wherever a believer is obliged to profess his faith and is not permitted to conceal it. In a land at war, however, if he is compelled to profess unbelief and fears for his life, then, should he outwardly profess unbelief, he must retain faith in his heart. If he does so, he is a believer but not a Muslim, for Allah, glorified and exalted is He, has called such a person a believer in His Book, saying:
“And a believing man from Pharaoh’s family, who concealed his faith, said” [Ghāfir: 28].
He also says:
“Except one who is compelled while his heart remains secure in faith” [al-Nahl: 106].
Yet he is not a Muslim