Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

knowing it. For knowledge encompasses what is necessary, possible, and impossible, as well as what exists and what does not exist. Action, however, pertains only to what is willed, and, according to those who hold this view, only what is possible in itself and wise to will is willed.

It is well known that a person is praised for not doing what is vile, not for not knowing it. He knows both the goodness and the badness of his actions. No one has ever said that our knowledge of the accounts of those who rejected the messengers, and of the evil deeds they committed, is an imperfection just as those deeds are imperfections. Rather, knowledge of good and evil is an attribute of perfection.

If it is said:

“What he means is that knowledge entails change or multiplicity,”

the reply is:

It is well known that this consequence follows even more necessarily from His bringing about multiple and changing things. For His bringing about multiple and changing things entails qualities subsisting in His essence. Yet this is not an imperfection, nor does His knowledge of them, with these necessary consequences, constitute an imperfection.

If it is said:

“Rather, His bringing about changing and multiple things does not entail multiple, changing qualities subsisting in His essence,”

the reply is:

If this is true, then His knowledge of them is even less likely to entail multiple, changing qualities subsisting in Him. For sound reason plainly recognizes that multiple and changing actions are more apt to entail multiplicity and successive occurrences in the acting essence than multiple and changing objects of knowledge are to entail multiplicity and successive occurrences in the essence

عن علمه به، فإن العلم يتعلق بالواجب والممكن، والممتنع والموجود والمعدوم، وأما الفعل فلا يتعلق إلا بما يراد، ولا يراد إلا ما هو ممكن في نفسه، وما تكون إرادته حكمةً على قول هؤلاء. ومعلوم أن الواحد من الناس يحمد بأنه لا يفعل القبيح، ولا يحمد بأن لا يعلمه، ويعلم حسن فعله ويعلم قبحه، ولم يقل أحد قط: إن علمنا بقصص المكذبين للرسل وما فعلوه من السيئات نقص، كما أن تلك الأفعال نقص، بل المعرفة بالخير والشر من صفات الكمال. وإن قيل: مراده أن العلم يلزم منه التغير أو التكثر. فيقال له: معلوم أن هذا اللازم لفعله المتكثرات والمتغيرات ألزم، فإن فعله للمتكثرات والمتغيرات يلزم منه قيام معان في ذاته، فليس ذلك نقصاً، ولا يكون في علمه بها مع هذه اللوازم نقص. وإن قيل: بل فعله للمتغيرات والمتكثرات لا يلزم منه قيام معان متكثرة متغيرة في ذاته. فيقال: إن كان هذا حقاً، فعلمه بها أولى أن لا يلزم منه قيام معان متكثرة متغيرة، فإنه من المعلوم بصريح العقل أن اقتضاء الأفعال المتكثرة والمتغيرة للتعدد والتجدد في الذات الفاعلة، أولى من اقتضاء المعلومات المتكثرة والمتغيرة للتعدد والتجدد في الذات

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies