Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

The underlying principle in all this is that only what has ceased to exist has entered into existence, and whatever has ceased to exist must have begun to exist, since only what began to exist can cease to exist. It would follow that an infinity extending into the past had entered into existence only if its entry into existence—I mean, that of the infinity—had been simultaneous. But when things enter into existence one individual after another in one and the same subject—as though you had said, in the revolving body—and there is no first, it does not follow that those which have entered into existence must be bounded or finite. For the finite is that to which something can be added, and any totality we suppose to be finite may contain a totality preceded by another totality.

This is the definition of the kind of infinity whose existence is possible: there is always something beyond it.

They should be asked: Just as the existence of the Creator, glorified and exalted be He, is conceived as infinite into the past, and just as His existence is conceived as infinite into the future—this is what we mean when we say that He has always existed and will always exist—are His acts in the past conceived as finite or infinite?

والأصل في هذا كله أن لا يدخل في الوجود إلا ما انقضى وجوده، وما انقضى وجوده ولا ينقضي إلا ما ابتدى وجوده، وإنما كان يلزم أن يدخل في الوجود ما لا نهاية له الماضي في الوجود، لو كان دخوله معا، أعني ما لا نهاية له، وأما الداخل فيه شخص فشخص على محل واحد، وكأنك قلت على الجسم الدوري وليس هناك أول، فليس يجب أن يكون ما دخل منها في الوجود منحصرا أو متناهيا، لأن المتناهي هو الذي يمكن يزاد عليه شيء، وأي جملة فرضناها متناهية فإنه يمكن أن يكون فيها جملة قبلها جملة أخرى. هذا هو حد ما لا نهاية له الجائز الوجود، أعنى أن يكون أبداً يوجد شيء خارج عنه، ويسألون: كما أن تقدير وجود الباري سبحانه وتعالى في الماضي غير متناه، وكما أن تقدير وجوده في المستقبل غير متناه ـوهذا معنى قولنا لم يزل ولا يزال: هل تقدر أفعاله في الماضي متناهية أو غير متناهية؟ .

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies