Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

god but Allah.’” He did not say, “Until they say that their Lord is a Lord,” for they already knew that.

The messengers only commanded them to join knowledge of tawhīd (divine oneness) with knowledge of lordship and oneness. They refused, whereas those who affirmed divine oneness accepted. Thus He said concerning the believers:

“Those who join what Allah has commanded to be joined.”

And He said concerning the unbelievers:

“And sever what Allah has commanded to be joined.”

The messengers therefore have a role in knowledge of tawhīd, but not in knowledge of oneness and lordship, for each kind of knowledge has its own station. Reason, acquired learning, intermediaries, reflection, and inference have no determining role in this knowledge, since it is universally present both in those capable of reflection and inference and in those incapable of them. Had He required them all to engage in reflection and inference, He would have imposed an excessive burden upon them: not everyone is capable of reflection and inference, whereas everyone can possess knowledge by necessity. He therefore required of them that which spared them such an excessive burden.

The hadith of the slave girl is well known, and she was among those incapable of reflection and inference. The same applies to the simple-minded, the insane, and others: if you asked them about Allah, glorified is He, they would point to Him on the basis of what He had made known to them. Thus He made Himself known directly before imposing religious obligations, and through messengers after imposing them. For had He addressed them and unveiled Himself to them before imposing religious obligations, without a messenger, religious obligation would have been nullified).

إله إلا الله» ، لم يقل: حتى يقولوا: إن ربهم رباً، إذ هم عارفون بذلك. وإنما أمرتهم الرسل أن يصلوا معرفة التوحيد بمعرفة الربوبية والوحدانية فأبوا، وقبل ذلك الموحدون، فقال في حال المؤمنين: {والذين يصلون ما أمر الله به أن يوصل} ، وقال في حال الكفار: {ويقطعون ما أمر الله به أن يوصل} . فالسفراء لهم مدخل في معرفة التوحيد دون معرفة الوحدانية والربوبية، إذ لكل معرفة مقام، فليس للعقل والكسب والوسائط والنظر والاستدلال في هذه المعرفة حكم، لكونها عامة موجودة ممن يصح منه النظر والاستدلال وممن لا يصح منه، فلو كلفهم كلهم النظر والاستدلال، لكان مكلفاً لهم شططاً، إذ لايصح من الكل النظر والاستدلال، ويصح من الكل المعرفة بالاضطرار، فحملهم من ذلك ما رفع به عنهم الشطط. وحديث الجارية فمشهور، وهي مما لا يصح منه النظر والاستدلال. وكذلك الأبله والمجنون وغيرهم، لو سألتهم عن الله سبحانه لأشاروا إليه بما عرفهم، فتعرف سبحانه قبل التكليف بنفسه وبعد التكليف بالسفراء، لأنه لو خطابهم وكاشفهم قبل التكليف بلا سفير لبطل التكليف) .

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies