Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

And Allah Most High says:

“Exalted is your Lord, the Lord of might, above what they describe.” [al-Sāffāt: 180].

There are many similar verses.

Most of the discourse condemned by the early generations contains falsehood and fabrication both in its propositions and in the proofs offered for them. Examples include the statements of the Jahmiyyah, who deny the names and attributes that Allah Most High has affirmed for Himself, and the discourse of the Qadariyyah, who deny what Allah has affirmed of His power and will.

The Jahmiyyah and those who negate the divine attributes base their reasoning on the argument from substances and accidents. They claimed that observable entities, such as the heavens and the earth, are composed of indivisible substances, or of matter and form; that a composite is preceded by its constituent parts and depends on someone to assemble it, and therefore has a beginning and is contingent; and that the attributes and movements inhering in these entities are accidents. These accidents—or some of them—have a beginning, and whatever has a beginning in its individual instances must also have a beginning as a kind. Thus, an infinite sequence of events is impossible.

They said: “Through this we came to know that the heavens are created, and through that we came to know that Allah exists.”

This reasoning consequently required them to deny Allah’s attributes and actions. That is false according to both revelation and reason, and what they put forward was not a sound proof. Thus, they neither came to know the truth through sound, upright proof, nor

وقال تعالى: {سبحان ربك رب العزة عما يصفون} [الصافات: ١٨٠] ، وأمثال ذلك. وعامة الكلام الذي ذمه السلف تشتمل مسائله على كذب وفرية، ودلائل مسائله على كذب وفرية، كأقوال الجهمية النفاة لما أثبته الله تعالى له من الأسماء والصفات، وكلام القدرية النافية لما أثبته الله من قدرته ومشيئته. ودلائل الجهمية والنفاة: هو استدلالهم بدليل الجواهر والأعراض، فإنهم زعموا أن الأعيان المشاهدة كالسماوات والأرض مركبة من الجواهر المنفردة، أو من المادة والصورة، وأن المركب مسبوق بجزئه، ومفتقر إلى مركب يركبه، فيكون محدثاً وممكناً، وما قام بها من الصفات والحركات أعراض، والأعراض - أو بعضها - حادثة، وما كان شخصه حادثاً، وجب أن يكون نوعه حادثاً، فيمتنع وجود حوادث لا تتناهى، قالوا: بهذا عرفنا أن السماوات مخلوقة، وبذلك عرفنا أن الله موجود، فلزمهم على ذلك أن ينفوا صفات الله وأفعاله، وذلك باطل شرعاً وعقلاً، ولم يكن ما أقاموه دليلاً صحيحاً، فلا هم عرفوا الحق بدليل صحيح قويم، ولا

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies