Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

If someone says that the True One is in a direction, intending something existent and distinct from Him, then nothing existent is distinct from Him except His creatures. If He is distinct from His creatures, how could they contain Him?

But if by “direction” he means what is above the world, there is no doubt that Allah is above the world, and there is nothing there but Him alone. Above created things there is only their Creator; He is the Most High, the Highest.

[Section]

As for Ibn Sīnā’s statement:

“Either it is obligatory to ascertain these meanings and master the true doctrine concerning them, or one may turn away from them and neglect inquiry and reflection upon them. If inquiry into them is waived, and mistaken beliefs concerning them incur no blame, then most of the doctrine of these people addressed by this statement is needless effort and can be dispensed with. But if it is a binding obligation, then it must be something explicitly stated in the revealed law.”

All of this is an argument against his brethren who deny the divine attributes, for they are the ones addressed by this statement. As for those who affirm the attributes, they maintain that all of this is explicitly stated in the revealed law.

Likewise, his statement: “Nor is it an exposition that is obscure, misleading, or confined

فقول القائل إن الحق في جهة إن أراد به ما هو موجود مباين له فلا موجود مباين له إلا مخلوقاته فإذا كان مبايناً لمخلوقاته فكيف تكون محتوية عليه؟ وإن أراد بالجهة ما فوق العالم فلا ريب أن الله فوق العالم وليس هناك إلا هو وحده وليس فوق المخلوقات إلا خالقها هو العلي الأعلى. [فصل] وقول ابن سينا فإنه لا يخلو إما أن تكون هذه المعاني واجباً تحققها وإتقان المذهب الحق فيها أو يسع الصدوف عنها وإغفال البحث والروية فيها فإن كان البحث عنها معفواً عنه وغلط الاعتقاد الواقع فيها غير مؤاخذ به فجل مذهب هؤلاء القوم المخاطبين بهذه الجملة تكلف وعنه غنية وإن كان فرضاً محكماً فواجب أن يكون مما صرح به في الشريعة. فهذا كله حجة على إخوانه نفاة الصفاة وهم المخاطبون بهذه الجملة واما أهل الإثبات فهم يقولون إن ذلك كله مما صرح به في الشريعة. وكذلك قوله وليس التصريح المعمى أو الملبس أو المقتصر

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies