Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

And changing wrongdoing means altering its character so that the wrong is removed as far as possible, even if this can only be achieved through an inward change in oneself—anger for Allah’s sake.

For this reason, an attribute inseparable from that which possesses it is not described as being other than it, since its possessor cannot pass into a state without that attribute or be separated from it.

“Otherness” and “change” derive from the same Arabic root. When something changes, its subsequent state is other than what it was before. Whatever has always retained the same attribute has not changed, nor are its attributes other than it.

When people are told that change is impossible for Allah, they understand this to mean transformation and corruption, such as attributes of perfection turning into attributes of deficiency, or the divine essence becoming divided, and similar things from which Allah must be declared free.

But His acting by His power—creating, rising, Himself doing whatever He wills, and speaking whenever He wills, and the like—is not something they call change.

Yet the arguments of those who deny His attributes rest on ambiguous, misleading expressions. As Imam Ahmad said:

“They speak in equivocal terms and confuse the ignorant with the ambiguities they present to them, until an ignorant person imagines that they are glorifying Allah, whereas their argument leads only to a false allegation against Allah.”

One of the most astonishing things is their appeal to the story of Abraham, Allah’s intimate friend. Despite their fabrications concerning its interpretation and the language, it is evidence against them, not in their favor, as stated by

وتغيير المنكر تبديل صفته حتى يزول المنكر بحسب الإمكان وغن لم يكن إلا بتغير الإنسان في نفسه غضباً لله ولهذا لم يطلق على الصفة الملازمة للموصوف أنها مغايرة له لأنه لا يمكن أن يستحيل عنها ولا يزايل والغير والتغير من مادة واحدة فإذا تغير الشيء صار الثاني غير ما كان فما لم يزل على صفة واحدة لم يتغير ولا تكون صفاته مغايرة له والناس إذا قيل لهم التغير على الله ممتنع فهموا من ذلك الاستحالة والفساد مثل انقلاب صفات الكمال إلى صفات نقص، أو تفرق الذات ونحو ذلك مما يجب تنزيه الله عنه وأما كونه سبحانه يتصرف بقدرته، فيخلق ويستوي ويفعل ما يشاء بنفسه ويتكلم إذا شاء، ونحو هذا لا يسمونه تغيراً ولكن حجج النفاة مبناها على ألفاظ مجملة موهمة كما قال الإمام أحمد: يتكلمون بالمتشابه من الكلام ويلبسون على جهال الناس بما يشبهون عليهم حتى يتوهم الجاهل أنهم يعظمون الله وهم إنما يقودون قولهم إلى فرية على الله ومن أعجب الأشياء احتجاجهم بقصة إبراهيم الخليل وهم مع افترائهم فيها على التفسير واللغة إنما هي حجة عليهم لا لهم كما قال

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies