Darʾ Taʿâroud al-ʿAql wa-n-NaqlIbn Taimiya

finite body must have a specific size and be enclosed by a single boundary, as in a sphere, or by several boundaries, as in a polyhedron—this is what is meant by shape—and must occupy a spatial location such that it can be pointed to as being here or there.

All of this is known self-evidently. Everything that has a specific shape, size, and spatial location must have a particularizer that assigns these to it.

The proof is that, for every body, it is self-evidently known that it could have a size larger or smaller than its actual size, a shape other than its actual shape, or a spatial location other than its actual location, either to its right or to its left. This being so, it must have a particularizer that assigns its particular attributes to it. Otherwise, one of two possibilities would be realized without a particularizer, which is impossible.

The second way is that the substances of the world must be either joined together, separate, both joined together and separate, neither joined together nor separate, or some of them

جسم متناه، فلا بد له من مقدار معين، وأن يحيط به حد واحد كالكري، أو حدود كالمضلع، وهو المعني بالشكل، وأن يكون في حيز بحيث يمكن أن يشار إليه بأنه ههنا أو هناك وهذا كله معلوم بالضرورة وكل ماله شكل ومقدار وحيز معين فلا بد له من مخصص يخصصه به وبرهانه أنه ما من جسم إلا ويعلم بالضرورة أنه يجوز أن يكون على مقدار أكبر أو أصغر مما هو عليه، أو شكل غير شكله، وحيز غير حيزه، إما متيامناً عنه أو متياسراً، وإذا كان كذلك فلا بد له من مخصص بما يخصص به، وإلا كان أحد الجائزين واقعاً من غير مخصص، وهو محال الطريق الثاني أن جواهر العالم إما أن تكون مجتمعة أو متفرقة، أو مجتمعة ومتفرقة معاً أو لا مجتمعة ولا متفرقة أو البعض

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies