Manāsik al-ḤajjIbn Taimiya

– Brandishing weapons upon arriving at Tabuk is an innovation. Our Shaykh added: it is forbidden. He went on to say: the tales the ignorant circulate about a “siege of Tabuk” are pure fabrication. ⦗al-Furūʿ 6/76; Ikhtiyārāt al-Baʿlī p. 177⦘.

Fawāt and Iḥṣār (missing the standing at ʿArafah and being impeded)

– If, by mistake, the people stand on the eighth or the tenth, it still suffices; Imām Aḥmad has explicit texts for both cases. Our Shaykh said: Does that mean it is, inwardly, the Day of ʿArafah? There is a difference of opinion on this within the Ḥanbalī school … Elsewhere he noted that two narrations from Aḥmad exist on the matter, and said: the second view is the correct one … Hence it is established that it is the Day of ʿArafah both inwardly and outwardly. ⦗al-Furūʿ 6/79⦘.

– A pilgrim prevented by illness or by the loss of his funds is treated like one blocked by an enemy; this is one of the two narrations from Aḥmad (1). ⦗al-Furūʿ 6/83; Ikhtiyārāt al-Baʿlī p. 377⦘.

Likewise (2): a menstruating woman who could not remain, was barred from ṭawāf, and returned without performing it—whether through ignorance of the obligation of ṭawāf al-ziyārah, because she was unable to do it, or because her companions departed. ⦗Majmūʿ al-Fatāwā 26/186-226; al-Furūʿ 6/83; Ikhtiyārāt al-Baʿlī p. 177⦘.

(1) According to the authoritative view of the school, a pilgrim who is prevented (al-muhsar) by illness or by the loss of his funds does not leave the state of ihram until he becomes able to reach the Sacred House. See: al-Insaf 4/71. (2) According to the same school, it is counted among the obligatory duties (wajibat) of the Hajj. See: al-Insaf 4/60.
- وشهر السلاح عند قدوم تبوك بدعة, زاد شيخنا: محرمة, قال: وما يذكره الجهال في حصار تبوك كذب. [الفروع ٦/ ٧٦، اختيارات البعلي ص ١٧٧] . الفوات والإحصار - وإن وقف الناس الثامن أو العاشر خطأ؛ أجزأ, نص عليهما, قال شيخنا: وهل هو يوم عرفة باطنًا؟ فيه خلاف في مذهب أحمد ... ، وذكر في موضع آخر: أن عن أحمد فيه روايتين, قال: والثاني الصواب ... , فعلم أنه يوم عرفة باطنًا وظاهرًا. [الفروع ٦/ ٧٩] . - والمحصر بمرض أو ذهاب نفقة: كالمحصر بعدو، وهو إحدى الروايتين عن أحمد (١) . [الفروع ٦/ ٨٣، اختيارات البعلي ص ٣٧٧] . ومثلهما: حائض تعذر مقامها وحرم طوافها، ورجعت ولم تطف؛ لجهلها بوجوب طواف الزيارة، أو لعجزها عنه، أو لذهاب الرفقة (٢) . [مجموع الفتاوى ٢٦/ ١٨٦ - ٢٢٦، الفروع ٦/ ٨٣، اختيارات البعلي ص ١٧٧] .
(١) والمذهب: أن المحصر بمرض أو ذهاب نفقة لا يتحلل حتى يقدر على البيت. ينظر: الإنصاف ٤/ ٧١. (٢) والمذهب: أنه من واجبات الحج. ينظر: الإنصاف ٤/ ٦٠.

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies