and al-Nawawī said, “Its chain of transmission is weak,” while Ibn al-Qayyim ruled, “It is not authentic.”

7 – Ibn al-Qayyim also noted: “The Prophet’s ﷺ practice, once he had finished burying the deceased, was to stand at the grave with his Companions, ask Allah to grant the deceased firmness, and instruct them to make the same supplication. He did not engage in prompting (talqīn) as people do today.”