Tashih Hadith Iftar al-Saim Qabla Safarahi Baad al-FajrNasir al-Din al-Albani

A corroborating narration from the Sunnah:

The corroboration from the Sunnah is the report recorded by Ahmad (6/398) through the route of Mansur al-Kalbi, from Dihyah ibn Khalifah (may Allah be pleased with him). He relates that he left his village for a place near the village of ʿUqbah during Ramadan, whereupon he broke his fast and a number of people broke theirs with him, while others were unwilling to do so. When he returned to his village he said, “By Allah, today I have witnessed something I never imagined I would see: a group of people have turned away from the guidance of the Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, and of his Companions.” He said this about those who had insisted on fasting, and then he prayed, “O Allah, take me unto You.”

Abu Dawud also recorded the narration (no. 2413).

I say: The transmitters of its chain are reliable—cited as authorities in the two Sahihs—apart from this Mansur. Al-ʿIjli said of him in Kitab al-Thiqat⦗1⦘, “An Egyptian Successor, trustworthy,” and Ibn Hibban likewise declared him reliable, listing him in al-Thiqat (1/124). However, Ibn al-Madini and others labeled him “unknown,” and that is the correct assessment.

(1) Entry no. 1375 in my personal copy of al-Subki’s Tartib Thiqat al-Ajli.
شاهد للحديث من السنة: أما الشاهد من السنة فهو ما أخرجه أحمد "٦/٣٩٨" من طريق منصور الكلبي عن دحية بن خليفة ﵁ أنه خرج من قريته إلى قريب من قرية عقبة في رمضان ثم إنه أفطر وأفطر معه ناس وكره آخرون أن يفطروا قال: فلما رجع إلى قريته قال: والله لقد رأيت اليوم أمرا ما كنت أظن أن أراه إن قوما رغبوا عن هدي رسول الله ﷺ وأصحابه يقول ذلك للذين صاموا ثم قال عند ذلك: "اللهم اقبضني إليك". وأخرجه أبو داود "رقم ٢٤١٣". قلت: ورجال إسناده ثقات محتج بهم في الصحيحين غير منصور هذا فقال فيه العجلي في "كتاب الثقات"١: "مصري تابعي ثقة" ووثقه ابن حبان أيضا فأورده في "الثقات" "١/١٢٤" لكن قال فيه ابن المديني وغيره: "مجهول" وهذا هو.
١ رقم "١٣٧٥" من نسختي من "ترتيب ثقاة العجلي" للسبكي.

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies