Abū al-ʿAbbās ibn Surayj relates from Ismāʿīl the Chief Judge:
“I once entered upon al-Muʿtaḍid while an array of handsome, fair-skinned Byzantine youths stood about his head. I looked at them, and al-Muʿtaḍid noticed me contemplating them. When I was about to leave, he signalled to me and said, ‘O judge! By Allah, never have I unfastened my trousers for anything unlawful (1).’
“On another occasion I visited him and he handed me a book. When I examined it, I found that it gathered together every legal concession drawn from the slips of the scholars. I said, ‘The person who compiled this is a heretic.’
“He replied, ‘Are not these ḥadiths authentic?’
“I said, ‘Indeed they are, but the one who deemed intoxicants permissible did not deem temporary marriage permissible, and the one who deemed temporary marriage permissible did not permit singing. No scholar is free of error, and whoever collects every error of the scholars will lose his religion.’ So he ordered the book to be burned (2).
Abū ʿAlī al-Muḥsin al-Tanūkhī said:
“It reached me that al-Muʿtaḍid was once seated in a house that was being built for him when he noticed among the workers a black man, ill-favoured of form, climbing the stairs two at a time and carrying twice what anyone else could carry. He found this suspicious, summoned the man, and asked him the reason for it. The fellow stammered. Ibn Ḥamdūn spoke up on his behalf, saying, ‘Who is this man that you should trouble your mind about him?’
“Al-Muʿtaḍid replied, ‘Something has crossed my mind, and I do not think it is groundless.’ He then ordered that the man be given one hundred lashes, threatened him with death, and called for the execution mat (3) and the sword. The man cried out, ‘Safety! I work at the brick-kiln. Some months ago a man came in wearing a money-pouch (4). He took out dinars. I pounced on him, covered his mouth, bound him, and hurled him into the kiln—while I kept the gold to strengthen my heart. Summon it!’ When they brought the pouch, the owner’s name was written on it, so a proclamation was made in