The qāḍī of Basra, Ibrāhīm ibn Muḥammad al-Taymī, used to say:
“Caliphs are three: Abū Bakr on the day of the Ridda, ʿUmar ibn ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz when he restored the properties usurped by the Umayyads, and al-Mutawakkil for eradicating innovations and championing the Sunnah.” ⦗1⦘
Yazīd ibn Muḥammad al-Muhallabī reported that al-Mutawakkil said to him, “The caliphs before me made themselves formidable so that people would obey them, whereas I show gentleness so that they will love me and obey me.” ⦗2⦘
Al-Aʿsam ⦗3⦘ related that ʿAlī ibn al-Jahm entered upon al-Mutawakkil while the caliph was turning two pearls over in his hand. The poet recited a qaṣīdah of his, whereupon the caliph rolled ⦗4⦘ one of the pearls toward him. I examined it ⦗5⦘, and he said, “Do you think it trivial? By Allah, it is worth more than one hundred thousand.” I replied, “No, by Allah; I was only reflecting on some verses that might earn me the other one,” and I began to say:
In Surr-Man-Raʾā a just imām (6) … from whose ocean even the seas draw;
Hoped for and feared in every crisis … as though he were Paradise and Hellfire.
Kingship is his and his sons’ (8) … for as long as night and day alternate;
Nothing issues from his right hand … without its like coming from the left (9).