complaining that the spring rain had scarcely visited them.
What harm would they suffer, were Jaʿfar to ride through their midst—
even if their springtime brought no rain at all?⦗1⦘
Different explanations have been offered for the manner in which Jaʿfar met his death.
One version relates that Jibrīl ibn Bakhtīshūʿ, the court physician,⦗2⦘ said: “I was sitting with al-Rashīd when Yaḥyā ibn Khālid entered; he used to come in without asking leave. He gave the greeting, and al-Rashīd returned it only weakly, whereupon Yaḥyā fell silent in confusion.
“Harun then asked me, ‘Jibrīl, does anyone enter upon you without permission?’
“‘No,’ I replied.
“‘Then what of us?’ he said.
“At that Yaḥyā leapt to his feet and said, ‘May Allah ever set me before you, Commander of the Faithful! By Allah, it was only a favor you singled me out for, and I now repent of it.’ Al-Rashīd felt abashed and said, ‘I meant nothing you would dislike, but people talk.’⦗3⦘
Another account, transmitted by Thumāmah, states: “The first thing that alerted Yaḥyā ibn Khālid to the change in his fortunes was that Muḥammad ibn al-Layth sent a letter to al-Rashīd admonishing him, in which he wrote: ‘Yaḥyā will avail you nothing before Allah.’ Al-Rashīd showed the letter to Yaḥyā and asked, ‘Do you know Muḥammad ibn al-Layth?’
“‘Yes,’ he answered, ‘he is suspect in matters of Islam.’
“So al-Rashīd had him imprisoned. When the Barmakids were struck down, he had Muḥammad brought before him and asked, ‘Do you love me?’
“‘No, by Allah,’ he replied.
“‘You say that?’
“‘Yes. You shackled my legs and kept me from my family without any fault of mine, save the word of a spiteful man who schemes against Islam and its people, and loves irreligion and its devotees.’
“Al-Rashīd released him and asked, ‘Do you love me now?’
“‘No, nor do I hate you,’ he said.
“So al-Rashīd ordered that one hundred thousand be given to him and asked again, ‘Do you love me?’
“He replied: