The narration goes on to relate that Abu Dharr gashed Kaʿb’s head. ʿUthmān then asked Kaʿb to forgo his right of retaliation, and Kaʿb agreed. ʿUthmān said, “Abu Dharr, fear Allah, and keep your hand and your tongue in check.”
Mūsā ibn ʿUbaydah reported: Ibn Nufayʿ (1) told us, on the authority of Ibn ʿAbbās, that Abu Dharr once sought permission to enter upon ʿUthmān. They ignored him for a while, so I said, “Commander of the Believers, Abu Dharr is at the door.”
He replied, “Let him in—if you wish to distress us and make things difficult for us.”
I allowed him in. He sat down on a marble-inlaid couch (2), and the couch shook beneath him—he was a tall, heavy man. ʿUthmān said, “Are you not the one who claims to be better than Abu Bakr and ʿUmar?”
Abu Dharr replied, “I never said that.”
ʿUthmān said, “I will bring evidence against you.”
Abu Dharr answered, “By Allah, I have no idea what evidence you will bring, though I know exactly what I have said.”
ʿUthmān asked, “Then what did you say?”
He replied, “I heard the Messenger of Allah ﷺ say, ‘The most beloved of you to me, the one closest to me, is the one who meets me while holding fast to the covenant upon which I left him.’ All of you have taken your portion of this world, whereas I remain upon that covenant; and with Allah lies the completion of grace.”
ʿUthmān posed other questions, which Abu Dharr answered according to his knowledge. ʿUthmān then ordered him to set out for Syria and join Muʿāwiyah. Once there, Abu Dharr would relate traditions, and the hearts of the people were captivated by him. Muʿāwiyah, however, disliked certain effects this had on his subjects, for Abu Dharr used to say:
“Let none of you keep a single dinar or dirham, or any gold or silver, overnight unless he spends it in the path of Allah or sets it aside to pay a debt.”
Muʿāwiyah once sent him a thousand dinars in the depths of night, and Abu Dharr distributed every last coin.