among the believers, and Allah knows best how his story came to an end.
Among his malicious utterances (1) are these verses:
Jesus came and the Law of Moses was set aside (2),
then Muhammad arrived with the five daily prayers.
They said, “There will be no prophet after this one,”
so the people went astray between tomorrow and yesterday (3).
However long you live in this world of yours (4),
it will never free you from moon or sun.
Whenever I speak impossibilities I raise my voice,
but when I state the truth (5) I keep my whisper long.
Among those who mourned him was his pupil Abū al-Hasan ʿAlī, who said (6):
If you never shed blood out of ascetic restraint,
today my eyelids have bled because of you.
You sent your remembrance (7) through the lands like musk,
so that any ear (8) that hears—or mouth that utters it—is perfumed.
I can almost see (9) the pilgrims: when by night they wish to recall you,
they would offer a ransom (10) on behalf of whoever is in consecration.
Among those who transmitted from him were Abū al-Qāsim ʿAlī ibn al-Muḥassin al-Tanūkhī—who died before him—and Ghālib ibn ʿĪsā al-Anṣārī.
His illness lasted three days, and he died in the opening days of Rabīʿ al-Awwal in 449 AH, having lived eighty-six years.