and that lying with our own daughters is lawful (1), permitted—
easy now, for this reproach (2) has gone on long enough.
They plunged ever deeper into error and would not repent (3);
yet, had they heard the clash of the sword, they would have repented.
He went on: Abū Tammām Ghālib ibn ʿĪsā in Mecca recited to us, and Abū al-ʿAlāʾ al-Maʿarrī recited, claiming the verses as his own (4):
From faith there reached me sixty proofs,
yet never did my hand grip the twin reins.
I possessed no house, not even a quarter of one,
and my heart felt no alarm on that account.
I remembered that I am doomed to die, son of one doomed to die;
so the earth and the two weighty races became trivial to me.
By this same chain al-Silafī said: “Among the evidences for the soundness of his creed is what I heard from the preacher Ḥāmid ibn Bakhtiyār—I heard Abū al-Mahdī (5) ibn ʿAbd al-Munʿim ibn Aḥmad al-Sarūjī—I heard my brother Abū al-Fatḥ the judge say:
‘I entered unexpectedly upon Abū al-ʿAlāʾ al-Tanūkhī in Maʿarra and heard him reciting (6):
How many a nubile maiden has been carried off (7),
while her aged mother lives on!
Her parents guard her in fear—
yet the grave is an impregnable fortress for her.
Death may miss its mark (8),
but everlasting life in this world is impossible.’
He then sighed several times and recited the Almighty’s words: “Indeed in that is a sign for whoever fears the punishment …”