Al-Sharḥ al-MumtiʿIbn al-'Uthaymin

because this allows him to escape, unlike testimony, in which case he is not allowed to do so.

However, what appears correct to me is that the matter is left to the judge’s discretion: if he considers digging a pit to be in the public interest, it should be dug; otherwise, it should not.

Then, according to the view that a pit is to be dug, we dig a pit for him but do not bury him in it. For if we were to bury him, he might not die, though he would be unable to move at all and would suffer. Whereas, if he remains able—for example—to turn in one direction and move slightly, it may ease the ordeal for him.

In summary, the general conditions are: legal maturity, soundness of mind, being subject to the rulings of Islam, and knowledge that the act is unlawful. These are conditions for every prescribed punishment, while other conditions are mentioned separately under each respective chapter.

لأجل أن يمكّن من الهرب، بخلاف البينة فإنه لا يُمَكَّن. ولكن الذي يظهر لي أن الأمر راجع إلى اجتهاد الحاكم، فإن رأى من المصلحة الحفر حفر وإلا فلا. ثم على القول بالحفر فإننا نحفر له ولا ندفنه؛ لأنه لو دفناه قد لا يموت، لكنه ما يتحرك أبداً، ويتعب فهو إذا بقي ربما ـ مثلاً ـ يلتفت إلى جهة، ويتحرك بعض الشيء ليهون عليه الأمر. فالخلاصة أن الشروط العامة هي: البلوغ، والعقل، والالتزام، والعلم بالتحريم، فهذه شروط في كل حد، وهناك شروط أخرى تذكر في كل باب على حدة.

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies