Al-Sharḥ al-MumtiʿIbn al-'Uthaymin

Undivided means shared: the working partner and the capital provider are partners in every unit of profit.

His statement, “If they do not specify the profit, or stipulate for either of them an unknown share, or a specified sum of dirhams, or the profit of one of the two garments, it is invalid”—all of these cases violate the condition.

“If they do not specify the profit, or stipulate for either of them an unknown share, or a specified sum of dirhams, or the profit of one of the two garments, it is invalid. The same applies to musāqāh (orchard sharecropping), muzāraʿah (crop sharecropping), and muḍārabah (profit-sharing investment partnership) …”

His statement, “If they do not specify the profit,” means that they merely say: “We are partners in an ʿinān partnership,” without addressing how the profit is to be divided: equally between them, by quarters, or the like. The partnership is invalid, because the matter remains unknown, leading to dispute and enmity between people. Each of them is entitled only to the profit generated by his own capital, and neither may claim anything from the other. Even if one of the two capitals is destroyed, its owner may not seek recourse from the other, because the contract is invalid, and an invalid contract does not produce its legal effects.

His statement, “or stipulate for either of them an unknown share,” means that they say: “We are now partners and will work with the capital; you shall have some of the profit and I shall have some of it,” or, “You shall have some of it and I shall have the rest.” This is invalid because it is unknown.

His statement, “or a specified sum of dirhams,” means that they say: “We shall enter into an ʿinān partnership, and you shall receive ten thousand of the profit, while the remainder is mine.” This is invalid, because perhaps

والمشاع أي: مشتركاً يكون المضارِب والمضارَب شريكين في كل حبة. قوله: «فإن لم يذكرا الربح أو شرطا لأحدهما جزءاً مجهولاً أو دراهم معلومة أو ربح أحد الثوبين لم تصح» كل هذه الصور مخالفة للشرط. َإِنْ لَمْ يَذْكُرَا الرِّبْحَ أو شَرَطَا لأحدِهِمَا جُزْءَاً مجهولاً أو دَرَاهِمَ مَعْلُومةً أَوْ رِبْحَ أَحَدِ الثَّوْبَيْنِ لَمْ تَصِحَّ وَكَذَا مُسَاقَاةٌ ومُزارعَةٌ ومُضَارَبةٌ ............ فقوله: «إن لم يذكرا الربح» بل قالا: نحن شريكان شركة عنان، ولم يتعرضا للربح، هل هو بينهما بالأنصاف؟ أو بالأرباع؟ أو ما أشبه ذلك؟ فالشركة لا تصح؛ لأنه يبقى الأمر مجهولاً فيحصل النزاع والعداوة بين الناس، ويكون لكل واحد منهما ربح ماله، ولا يرجع على الثاني بشيء، حتى لو تلف أحد المالين لم يرجع على صاحبه؛ لأن العقد فاسد، والعقد الفاسد لا يترتب عليه أثره. وقوله: «أو شرطا لأحدهما جزءاً مجهولاً» قال: نحن الآن شريكان سنعمل في المال، ولك بعض الربح ولي بعضه، أو لك بعضه ولي باقيه، فهذا لا يصح؛ لأنه مجهول. وقوله: «أو دراهم معلومة» قال: سنشترك شركة عنان والربح يكون لك منه عشرة آلاف والباقي لي، فهذا لا يصح؛ لأنه ربما

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies