Al-Sharḥ al-MumtiʿIbn al-'Uthaymin

Some scholars hold that the imam should not wait for one who enters the mosque at all, even if he enters while the imam is bowing in the final rakʿah, by which the congregational prayer may be caught. They say: the prayer has a prescribed form known in the Sacred Law, so it should not be altered in consideration of anyone.

But the correct view is the detailed distinction mentioned previously.

His statement, “so long as this does not cause hardship to a follower,” is a qualification of the previous issue. Thus, if it causes hardship to a follower, he should not wait. But should we say that doing so is disliked, or prohibited?

The answer is that the apparent indication of the sunnah is that it is prohibited, for the Prophet ﷺ rebuked Muʿādh (1) when he unduly lengthened the prayer. Likewise, one who waits and prolongs the waiting has lengthened it at a time when such lengthening is not prescribed for him—like one who lengthens the recitation at a time when it is not prescribed. It is therefore unlawful for him.

It may also be understood from the words of the author, may Allah have mercy on him, that the one who came earlier is more deserving of consideration than the one who came later. Hence, we forgo the interest of the latecomer out of consideration for the earlier attendee. And this is indeed so.

If a woman asks permission to go to the mosque, it is disliked to prevent her, though her home is better for her.

His statement, “If a woman asks permission to go to the mosque, it is disliked to prevent her.”

“If she asks permission,” that is, she seeks permission. “Woman” here refers to an adult female. It may also refer to a female even if she has not reached adulthood; however, most commonly, the term “woman,” like the term “man,” refers to one who has reached adulthood. Thus, if she seeks permission from her guardian, and she has a husband,

(1) Its source has been cited above (192).
وذهبَ بعضُ أهلِ العِلمِ: إلى أنَّه لا ينتظرُ الدَّاخلَ مطلقاً، حتى وإنْ كان دخولُه في الرُّكوعِ في الركعةِ الأخيرةِ الذي تُدركُ به الجماعةُ، قال: لأنَّ الصلاةَ لها هيئةٌ معلومةٌ في الشَّرعِ، فلا ينبغي أن تُغَيَّرَ مِن أجلِ مراعاةِ أحدٍ. ولكن؛ الصحيحُ: ما سَبَقَ تفصيلُه. وقوله: «ما لم يشق على مأموم» وهذا قيدُ المسألةِ السَّابقةِ، وهو: أنَّه إذا شَقَّ على مأموم فإنَّه لا ينتظرُ، ولكن؛ هل نقولُ: إنَّه يكون مكروهاً، أو يكون ممنوعاً؟ الجواب: ظاهرُ السُّنةِ أنَّه يكون ممنوعاً؛ لأنَّ النَّبيَّ ﷺ أنكرَ على مُعاذ (١) حينما أطالَ إطالةً غيرَ مشروعةٍ، وهذا الذي انتظرَ وأطالَ الانتظارَ قد أطالَه في حالٍ لا يُشرعُ له فيه ذلك، مثل مَن أطالَ القراءةَ في حالٍ لا تُشرعُ فيها، فإنَّه حرامٌ عليه. ويؤخذُ مِن كلامِ المؤلِّفِ ﵀: أنَّ السابقَ أَولى بالمُراعاةِ مِن اللاحقِ، ولهذا فَوَّتنا مصلحةَ الدَّاخلِ مراعاةً للسابقِ، وهو كذلك. وَإِذَا اسْتَأْذَنَتْ المَرْأَةُ إِلَى المَسْجِدِ كُرِهَ مَنْعُهَا وَبَيْتُهَا خَيْرٌ لَهَا. قوله: «وإذا استأذنت المرأةُ إلى المسجد كره منعها». «إذا استأذنت» أي: طلبت الإذنَ و «المرأة» يُرادُ بها البالغةُ، وقد يُرادُ بها الأنثى، وإنْ لم تكن بالغةً، ولكن؛ الأكثرُ أنَّ المرأةَ كالرَّجُلِ؛ إنما تُطلق على البالغةِ، كما أنَّ الرَّجُلَ يُطلقُ على البالغِ، فإذا طَلبت الإذنَ مِن وليِّ أمرِها، فإن كانت ذاتَ زوجٍ
(١) تقدم تخريجه (١٩٢).

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies