Al-Sharḥ al-MumtiʿIbn al-'Uthaymin

Third: waiting for someone entering the mosque during a pillar of the prayer other than bowing; that is, during a pillar in which he cannot catch the rakʿah, and which is not counted for him. This is of two types:

The first type: that in which some benefit is attained.

The second type: that in which there is no benefit, other than joining the imam in the act he is performing.

An example of the first type is when someone enters during the final tashahhud. In this case, waiting is good, because there is a benefit in it: according to some scholars, he catches the congregational prayer. We have previously mentioned the author’s statement: “Whoever says the takbīr before his imam gives the salām has caught the congregation” (1).

There is also a benefit in it even according to the view that he has not caught the congregation, because catching this portion is better than missing it altogether; thus, he benefits from it.

An example of the second type is that in which there is no benefit with respect to catching the congregational prayer, apart from merely following the imam. For instance, if the imam is prostrating in the third rakʿah of a four-rakʿah prayer and senses someone entering, then it is not recommended for him to wait. The entering congregant gains nothing from this waiting with respect to catching the congregational prayer, since he will catch the final rakʿah. Moreover, if we were to say that he should wait, this would entail two things:

First: it may cause hardship to some of the congregants, even if only psychologically, for some people lack chivalrous character and do not wish good for others.

Second: it alters the established manner of the prayer, because he would lengthen this pillar more than the one before it. This is contrary to the manner of the prayer, for its proper manner is that its latter part be shorter than its beginning.

(1) See p. 168.
الثالث: انتظار الدَّاخلِ في رُكنٍ غيرِ الرُّكوعِ، أي: في رُكنٍ لا يُدركُ فيه الرَّكعةَ ولا يُحسبُ له، فهذا نوعان: النوع الأول: ما تحصُلُ به فائدةٌ. النوع الثاني: ما ليس فيه فائدةٌ، إلا أن يشاركَ الإِمامُ فيما اجتمع معه فيه. مثال النوع الأول: إذا دخلَ في التشهُّدِ الأخيرِ، فهنا الانتظارُ حَسَنٌ؛ لأنَّ فيه فائدةً، وهي: أنه يدركُ صلاةَ الجماعةِ عند بعضِ أهلِ العِلمِ، فقد مرَّ بنا قولُ المؤلِّفِ: «مَن كبَّرَ قبل سلامِ إمامِهِ لَحِقَ الجماعةَ» (١). وأيضاً: فيه فائدة؛ حتى على القولِ بعدمِ إدراكِ الجماعةِ؛ لأنَّ إدراكَ هذا الجُزءِ خيرٌ مِن عدمِهِ فهو مستفيدٌ. ومثال النوع الثاني: ما ليس فيه فائدة في إدراكِ الجماعةِ؛ إلا مجرد المتابعة للإِمام، مثل: أن يكون ساجداً في الرَّكعةِ الثالثة في الرُّباعيةِ فأحسَّ بداخلٍ، فهنا لا يُستحبُّ الانتظار؛ لأنَّ المأمومَ الداخلَ لا يستفيدُ بهذا الانتظارِ شيئاً في إدراكِ الجماعةِ، إذ سيدركُ الرَّكعةَ الأخيرةَ، ولو قلنا بالانتظارِ لاستلزم شيئين: الأول: أنَّه قد يَشُقُّ على بعضِ المأمومين، ولو نفسيًّا؛ لأنَّ بعضَ الناسِ ليس عنده مروءةً، ولا يحبُّ الخيرَ للغير. الثاني: أنه يغيِّرُ هيئةَ الصلاَّةِ؛ لأنَّه سوف يُطيلُ هذا الرُّكنَ أكثر مما سبقه، وهذا خِلافُ هيئةِ الصَّلاةِ؛ لأنَّ هيئةَ الصلاةِ: أنْ يكون آخرُها أقصرُ مِن أوَّلِها.
(١) انظر: ص (١٦٨).

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies