Al-Sharḥ al-MumtiʿIbn al-'Uthaymin

it was said that precedence is given to whichever is greater in number. For example, if someone concludes his prayer with the salām before completing it, bows twice in one rak‘ah, and omits the first tashahhud, then there are two reasons requiring the prostration to be after the salām—namely, the additional bowing and concluding the prayer before its completion—and one reason requiring the prostration to be before the salām, namely, omitting the first tashahhud. Thus, the prostration is performed after the salām.

Another example: a man bows twice in one rak‘ah and omits saying, “Glory be to my Lord, the Magnificent,” while bowing, and, “Glory be to my Lord, the Most High,” while prostrating. Here, two reasons requiring the prostration to be before the salām have come together—omitting the glorification in bowing and in prostration—along with one reason requiring it to be after the salām, namely, the additional bowing. Thus, the prostration is before the salām.

The established position of the school (1), however, gives precedence to what is before the salām in all cases, because its compensatory prostration is obligatory and its proper place is before one says the salām. Therefore, promptly making up for the deficiency in the prayer before completing it is more appropriate than delaying the compensatory act.

The third volume is complete, with praise to Allah Most High.

It will be followed, by the will of Allah, exalted is His majesty, by the fourth volume, which begins with the Chapter on Voluntary Prayer.

(1) Al-Insaf, 4:91.
فقيل: يعتبر ما هو أكثر، مثل: لو سَلَّمَ قبل تمام صلاته وَرَكَعَ في إحدى الرَّكعات رُكوعين، وتَرَكَ التشهُّدَ الأوَّل، فهنا عندنا سببان يقتضيان أن يكون السُّجود بعد السَّلام، وهما زيادة الرُّكوع والسَّلام قبل التمام، وعندنا سببٌ واحدٌ يقتضي السُّجود قبل السَّلام، وهو تَرْك التشهُّد الأول، فيكون السُّجودُ بعد السَّلام. مثال آخر: رَجُلٌ رَكَعَ في رَكعَة رُكُوعين، وتَرَكَ قول: «سُبحان رَبِّي العظيم» في الرُّكوع، وقول: «سُبحان رَبِّيَ الأعلى» في السُّجودِ، فهنا اجتمعَ سببان للسُّجودِ قبل السَّلام، وهما: تَرْكُ التَّسبيح في الرُّكوع وفي السُّجود، وسببٌ واحد يقتضي أن يكون السُّجود بعد السَّلام، وهو زيادة الرُّكوع، فالسُّجود قبل السَّلام. والمذهب (١) يُغَلِّبُ ما قبلَ السَّلام مطلقاً؛ لأن ما قبل السَّلام جابره واجب، ومحلُّه قبل أن يُسلِّمَ، فكانت المبادرة بجَبْرِ الصَّلاة قبل إتمامها أَولى مِن تأخير الجابر. تم بحمد الله تعالى المجلد الثالث ويليه بمشيئة الله ﷿ المجلد الرابع وأوله باب صلاة التطوع
(١) «الإنصاف» (٤/ ٩١).

Company

  • About
  • Pricing
  • Why Translate?

Support

  • Contact us
  • Report a bug
  • Support us
  • Donate
  • AI combat arena

Follow us

© 2026 Kutub. All rights reserved.
Terms and conditionsPrivacy policyCookies